In an attempt to provide some feedback to both the BOD and the members in general, I conducted a poll based on member perception of BOD compliance with its stated values. The subject HOA was the same SCG studied in the “mgmt case study” posts.
In this era of disinformation, of co-opting groups and ideas, and politicians no longer avoiding the illusion of impropriety but lying straight to your face, facts — undisputable facts — are important. If we are to succeed in finding the truth, it is necessary to accept the world as it is, and to rise above it. This poll attempts to discover the truth about SCG in order to rise above the realities as they are.
“Reliability” refers to getting the same results on repeated polls with different groups. (That’s basically what “significance” is all about and is determined by statistical methodology). Appropriate to HOA member attitudes in general, I read studies and polls that 80% love their HOA or 70% believe their BOD is great, etc. Does that mean that all the members or group believe so, or just those who responded? In other words, as others have raised, “what’s the point” or “it’s meaningless.”
As you can see below, the responses are relatively steady for the 5 checkpoints, with a dip and recovery for questions 2 and 6.
![](https://pvtgov.info/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/scg-values-trend-fb.png?w=1024)
Here’s how my small sample responded to the SCG 6 statements of value. Surprised? The strength of the Agree choices varies according to the question, from a low of 43.9% to a high of 91.4%. All in all, the average Agree response comes to 63.8%, or let’s say two-thirds. Congratulations! But, looking at the individual questions, there is more that can be accomplished with proactive involvement by members not afraid of change and of criticizing the BOD.
![](https://pvtgov.info/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/scg-value-chart-59.png?w=1024)
In response to concerns of “what’s the point?” and “it’s meaningless,” that depends on member reaction. It is meaningful and provides direction for positive action if the members escape from their apathy, for whatever reason, and make it so. To quote Teddy Roosevelt, “The credit belongs to the man who is actually in the arena . . . who does actually strive to do the deeds.
With SCG’s obsession with keeping property values up by attracting, new members who would be, for the most part “young-uns,” a more detailed survey is in order. Using the same Value statements, are there differences between newbies and oldies based on age or years of membership? However, due to the buying “panic” driving home prices sky high, now would not be a good time for the survey. It does reflect that home prices are still dominated by the marketplace.
Sun City Grand HOA members, you can take the poll anonymously. Click: SCG values poll.